Running a Content Moderation Programme: A Practitioner's Guide to Policy Drafting, Appeals, Transparency, and Regulatory Exposure
By Casey Scott McKay ·
This guide is for counsel building or repairing a content moderation programme. It is organised around the observation that legitimacy in this function comes from process rather than from outcomes. Nobody agrees with every decision and nobody ever will; what can be defended is that the rule was published, the definition was stated, the decision was recorded, the user was told what was applied, and there was a route to challenge it. The guide covers policy architecture and the separation of public rules from enforcement guidance, notice generation, and appeal design. It then addresses the distinct handling the copyright queue requires, account actions, trusted flagger and reviewer governance, and vendor contracting for outsourced review. It closes with transparency methodology, coordinated behaviour enforcement, the obligations around minors, and the constitutional and state law layer that keeps moving.
IP and Technology > Internet | Guide | Published 22 October 2025 - Updated 4 April 2026 | Casey Scott McKay - marksy.us
Summary. This guide is for counsel building or repairing a content moderation programme, and it is organised around the observation that legitimacy in this function comes from process rather than from outcomes. Nobody agrees with every decision; what can be defended is that the rule was published, the definition was stated, the decision was recorded, the user was told what was applied, and there was a route to challenge it. It covers policy architecture and the separation of public rules from enforcement guidance, notice generation, appeal design, the distinct handling the copyright queue requires, account actions, reviewer governance, transparency methodology, coordinated behaviour, and obligations around minors.
Keywords: moderation programme · policy drafting · enforcement guidance · reviewer agreement testing · notice generation · appeal design · account actions · copyright queue separation · trusted flagger governance · transparency methodology · coordinated behaviour · minors and age assurance · outsourced review contracts · decision records · government referrals
This is premium Marksy content — the full document is available to subscribers.